But finding a good scary podcast worth listening to can be difficult. So, here’s a list of some of the best horror podcasts you won’t regret giving a chance.
1. 13 Days of Halloween
13 Days of Halloween is a podcast co-produced by iHeart3DAudio, Blumhouse Television, and Grim&Mild from Aaron Mahnke. Blumhouse is one of the most well-known production companies focusing on horror content. Sure some of their movies are quite cheesy and camp, but there’s nothing wrong with getting your fix of cheesy horror.
Blumhouse is also behind some of the best horror-themed films, so the podcast expectations are high. Fortunately, it meets them. The horror podcast presents compelling stories best heard through headphones—that way, you are totally immersed and can catch every sound. 13 Days of Halloween begins on October 19, 2022, and ends on Halloween, with daily episodes.
Each episode focuses on the story of a different resident of a creepy hotel, with Keegan-Michael Key as the hotel’s caretaker.
2. Web Crawlers
Melissa Stetten and Ali Segel host the Web Crawlers podcast. They go over famous creepy, spooky, and generally odd topics that everyone seems to have heard of and knows, at least on a surface level.
That includes anything from UFO sightings to the ghostly horrors of the Cecil Hotel in Los Angeles, mysteries like the lost colony of Roanoke, and so on. But despite the severity of the topics covered, the hosts keep a casual, easygoing tone while going through rabbit holes, conspiracy theories, and more.
Web Crawlers offers a way to dip your toes into horrific events while keeping the tone light and casual. So it’s not super high on the scare meter.
3. The Scaredy Cats Horror Show
Have you heard praise for a horror movie but are too scared to watch it? Even if you use a site to watch the horror flick online for free, do you still find it too scary to see? Well, The Scaredy Cats Horror Show podcast is for you.
The podcast covers all the horror movies people may be too scared to watch, old and new. Back to back, you can hear an episode on The Exorcist, Hereditary, and Midsommar.
The podcast’s concept is simple—the hosts watch scary flicks in an attempt to cure themselves of being too scared to watch scary flicks. So if you’re too scared to watch yourself, you can listen to them go through the horror while you sit back and enjoy.
4. Pretty Scary
Pretty Scary is a podcast covering a slew of scary topics, like conspiracy theories, ghosts and aliens, true crime, and so on. And since the hosts are a group of comedians, you’re in no danger of getting too scared. So the topics may be horrific, but the hosts keep the discussion casual and easygoing.
You’ll feel like you’re chatting with friends in a cafe.
5. Into the Dark
Into the Dark delves into the occult, focusing on witchcraft. The podcast offers a glimpse into the lives of those who practice the occult arts through interviews.
The host, Cooper B. Wilhelm, asks various questions, including ones submitted by the podcast audience. So, topics are as varied as the queries themselves. Into the Dark is only 23 episodes, so it’s quite easy to binge.
6. Borrasca
Borrasca is an acclaimed podcast that won the award for Podcast Scripted Fiction. It’s a gripping psychological thriller mystery worth consuming.
Each episode offers a new glimpse into the life of Sam Walker, voiced by Cole Sprouse. The first season covers Sam’s move to a new town and the mystery that unfolds there, and the second continues the story and is just as thrilling.
Borrasca feels like a full-fledged TV series and certainly delivers on spookiness.
7. Unexplained
Unexplained is a story-based podcast that delves into all manner of unexplained mysteries. The host and creator, Richard MacLean Smith, crafts an eerie atmosphere that boasts the experience of the story being told to you—it’s awesome to enjoy with headphones.
Unexplained is a creepy podcast primarily focusing on the paranormal, leaving its listeners questioning reality at the end of each episode. It’s worth checking out.
8. Superstitions
Superstitions is a podcast covering the meaning behind the most well-known superstitions. Like, why do you cross your fingers? Or why is the number 666 considered bad? So, if that’s of interest to you, give it a listen.
Episodes explore origins, myths, folklore, histories, and everything related to various superstitions, as well as what follows if you do or do not do something—like throwing salt behind your back after you spill some, for example.
Is there anything supernatural behind superstitions? Why have some endured while others were abandoned? Superstitions is low on the horror scale, so if you’re a hardened horror fan, you might be better off exploring some of the scariest corners of the internet. The Superstition podcast is for those looking to dip their toes into horror.
9. Extraterrestrial
It’s hardly surprising that the Extraterrestrial podcast focuses on the expansive topic of alien life—are we alone in the universe? Why do some believe we are despite the vastness of the known universe? Who is right, and who is wrong?
Extraterrestrial features stories about alien encounters, elaborating on theories of alien occurrences, abductions, and more while also offering more grounded explanations of how the events discussed unfolded. Each episode shares a tale about reported alien happenings, examines all possible explanations, and lands on the most plausible one.
10. Haunted Places
Haunted Places offers tours exploring haunted locations while providing backstories about the apparent apparitions and paranormal events. It’s a global podcast that doesn’t limit itself to only one country.
So, you can traverse and hear about the Cecil Hotel in Los Angeles and move on to the catacombs of Paris next. Haunted Places offers a look into horrific destinations that can give you chills just hearing about them.
11. Lore
Lore’s tagline is ‘‘Sometimes the truth is more frightening than fiction,’’ and that’s its focus. So if you’re looking for a horror podcast showcasing spooky fiction inspired by true-life scary stories, look no further.
The podcast episodes showcase real-life stories derived from historical events, delving into the motivations behind them, the aftermath, the people, and everything surrounding a certain event. It also covers folklore and ghost stories, ancient and modern.
12. Dr. Death
A word of caution: You should prepare for a gruesome journey if you decide to listen to the Dr. Death podcast.
The horrors that the Dr. Death podcast explores are real-life crimes committed by one doctor, Dr. Christopher Duntsch. He’s guilty of performing countless botched surgeries on multiple patients of his for years on end.
The podcast host, Laura Beil, is a health and science journalist. She discusses the doctor’s deeds, how they ended for the patients who suffered from them, and the doctor’s potential motives behind his malpractice. Alongside that, Beil also showcases how the American healthcare system failed the patients of the horrific doctor.
13. Monsters Among Us
Monsters Among Us explores all manner of unexplainable phenomena. You can listen to episodes discussing the paranormal with ghost encounters, UFO sightings, cryptids, and more.
Derek Hayes hosts the podcast, but the stories discussed come from real-life people calling in to share their experiences. So, you hear people tell their stories themselves, like listening to a voicemail. And you get a candid glimpse into their encounters.
Monsters Among Us is a captivating podcast that feels genuine thanks to real-life callers. During an episode, you’ll hear about an encounter, then proceed to a discussion aiming to debunk the beliefs and offer a non-bizarre explanation. It’s a pretty compelling podcast.
Don’t Want to Listen to Horror? Watch It
Shudder and Screambox are among the most well-known streaming platforms offering horror-centric content. So, give either one a try the next time you’re in the mood to watch horror.
